Suggestions by @frachlitz

Dara Reneé

as Frankie Healy in Jagged Little Pill

Score: +26

Neil Patrick Harris

as Steve Healy in Jagged Little Pill

Score: +27

Amy Adams

as Mary Jane Healy in Jagged Little Pill

Score: +27

Carson MacCormac

as Romeo Montague in & Juliet

Score: +28

Ross Lynch

as Romeo Montague in & Juliet

Score: +10

Andy Nyman

as Lance Du Bois in & Juliet

Score: +22

Joe Serafini

as François Du Bois in & Juliet

Score: +25

Da'Vine Joy Randolph

as Angélique in & Juliet

Score: +17

Maya Rudolph

as Angélique in & Juliet

Score: +27

Amandla Stenberg

as May in & Juliet

Score: +27

James Marsden

as William Shakespeare in & Juliet

Score: +28

Anne Hathaway

as Anne Hathaway in & Juliet

Score: +31

China Anne McClain

as Juliet Capulet in & Juliet

Score: +32

Yvette Nicole Brown

as Nurse Norma in Waitress

Score: +15

Steve Martin

as Joe in Waitress

Score: +13

Danny DeVito

as Cal in Waitress

Score: +12

Ethan Slater

as Ogie Anhorn in Waitress

Score: +20

Dominic West

as Earl Hunterson in Waitress

Score: +17

Halle Bailey

as Dawn in Waitress

Score: +28

Keala Settle

as Becky in Waitress

Score: +28