Suggestions by @ethelthecreator

Sam Claflin

as James Carey in The Rachel Incident

Score: +3

Paul Mescal

as Ben in The Rachel Incident

Score: +4

Jack Champion

as Chris Murray in The Rachel Incident

Score: +3

Greta Gerwig

as Director in The Rachel Incident

Score: +4

Jordan Fisher

as Jonathan in The Rachel Incident

Score: +4

Brendan Gleeson

as Rachel's Dad in The Rachel Incident

Score: +4

Laurie Metcalf

as Rachel's Mum in The Rachel Incident

Score: +3

Jack Champion

as Kevin Murray in The Rachel Incident

Score: +1

Alison Oliver

as Sabrina in The Rachel Incident

Score: +4

Kerry Condon

as Aideen Harrington-Byrne in The Rachel Incident

Score: +4

Colin Farrell

as Dr. Fred Byrne in The Rachel Incident

Score: +3

Troye Sivan

as James Devlin in The Rachel Incident

Score: +2

Daisy Edgar-Jones

as Rachel Murray in The Rachel Incident

Score: 0

Karan Brar

as Kevin Gnapoor in Mean Girls

Score: +3

Mason Gooding

as Shane Oman in Mean Girls

Score: +3

John Cena

as Coach Carr in Mean Girls

Score: +4

Don Cheadle

as Principal Duvall in Mean Girls

Score: +4

Katherine Heigl

as Mrs. George in Mean Girls

Score: +3

Carey Mulligan

as Mrs. Norbury in Mean Girls

Score: +4

Jaquel Spivey

as Damien Hubbard in Mean Girls

Score: +3