Suggestions by @ethelthecreator

Sophia Lillis

as Alma Del Mar Jr. in Brokeback Mountain

Score: +3

Chris Hemsworth

as Randall Malone in Brokeback Mountain

Score: +1

Naomi Scott

as Lashawn Malone in Brokeback Mountain

Score: +1

Victoria Pedretti

as Cassie Cartwright in Brokeback Mountain

Score: +2

Vince Vaughn

as Joe Aguirre in Brokeback Mountain

Score: +2

Melissa Barrera

as Lureen Newsome Twist in Brokeback Mountain

Score: +2

Aaron Taylor-Johnson

as Jack Twist in Brokeback Mountain

Score: +1

Jessie Buckley

as Alma Beers Del Mar in Brokeback Mountain

Score: +2

Ben Hardy

as Ennis Del Mar in Brokeback Mountain

Score: +1

Robert Eggers

as Director in Purgatorio

Score: +2

Willem Dafoe

as The Hermit in Purgatorio

Score: +2

Storm Reid

as Hanna in Purgatorio

Score: +1

Monica Bellucci

as Satana in Purgatorio

Score: +2

Chris Messina

as Donate in Purgatorio

Score: +1

Esther Garrel

as Mona in Purgatorio

Score: +1

Barry Keoghan

as Rufus in Purgatorio

Score: +2

Brandon Perea

as Leo in Purgatorio

Score: +1

Henry Cavill

as Dominic in Purgatorio

Score: +2

Florence Pugh

as Cherie in Purgatorio

Score: +1

Rosamund Pike

as Nicola Devlin in The Rachel Incident

Score: +4