Suggestions by @emmatorretti

Thomas Kuc

as Noah Baker in Sadie

Score: +1

Dove Cameron

as Kendall Baker in Sadie

Score: 0

Zach Woods

as Caddy Sinclair in Sadie

Score: +1

Billy Zane

as Saul Lockwood in Sadie

Score: +1

Catherine Zeta-Jones

as Ruby Lockwood in Sadie

Score: +2

Arielle Kebbel

as Marlee Singer in Sadie

Score: -1

Charlie Hunnam

as Silas Baker in Sadie

Score: +1

Daniel Gillies

as Edward Colburn in Sadie

Score: +1

Cameron Diaz

as Claire Southern in Sadie

Score: +1

Julianne Moore

as Norah Stackett in Sadie

Score: +1

Laurence Fishburne

as Detective George Alfonso in Sadie

Score: +1

James McAvoy

as Carl Earl in Sadie

Score: +1

Kathy Bates

as May Beth Foster in Sadie

Score: +3

Alec Baldwin

as West McCray in Sadie

Score: -1

Odeya Rush

as Sadie Hunter in Sadie

Score: -1

Odeya Rush

as Mattie Southern in Sadie

Score: -6

Elle Fanning

as Mattie Southern in Sadie

Score: -1