Suggestions by @emmatorretti

Claudia Lee

as Violet Markey in All The Bright Places

Score: -1

Dacre Montgomery

as Al Tripodi in Lucky

Score: +1

Nadji Jeter

as Gregory Madison in Lucky

Score: +1

Rita Moreno

as Myra Narbonne in Lucky

Score: +1

Rupert Grint

as Paul Breuninger in Lucky

Score: +1

Jordana Brewster

as Tess Gallagher in Lucky

Score: +1

Tyler Marcel Williams

as Victor in Lucky

Score: +1

Tyler Millard

as Victor in Lucky

Score: -1

Ester Expósito

as Mary Alice in Lucky

Score: +2

Alison Thornton

as Alice in Lucky

Score: +1

Elizabeth Olsen

as Amanda in Sadie

Score: +1

Ron Perlman

as Joe Perkins in Sadie

Score: +1

Jacob Elordi

as Ellis Jacobs in Sadie

Score: +1

Amanda Donohoe

as Sally Quinn in Sadie

Score: +1

Saoirse Ronan

as Cat Mather in Sadie

Score: +1

Seth Green

as Paul Good in Sadie

Score: +1

Tom Cavanagh

as Jack Hersh in Sadie

Score: +2

Willem Dafoe

as Lenny Henderson in Sadie

Score: +1

Danielle Rose Russell

as Carrie Sandoval in Sadie

Score: +1

Kyle Schmid

as Javi Cruz in Sadie

Score: -1