Suggestions by @dreamingofyou

Irene Molloy

as Gina Kinkaid in Beverly Hills 90210 (2000-2010)

Score: +1

Majandra Delfino

as Clare Arnold in Beverly Hills 90210 (2000-2010)

Score: +2

Lizzy Caplan

as Clare Arnold in Beverly Hills 90210 (2000-2010)

Score: +2

Jessica Szohr

as Valerie Malone in Beverly Hills 90210 (2000-2010)

Score: 0

Michelle Trachtenberg

as Valerie Malone in Beverly Hills 90210 (2000-2010)

Score: +1

Alyson Hannigan

as Andrea Zuckerman in Beverly Hills 90210 (2000-2010)

Score: +1

Justin Timberlake

as David Silver in Beverly Hills 90210 (2000-2010)

Score: +1

Leonardo DiCaprio

as Steve Sanders in Beverly Hills 90210 (2000-2010)

Score: +1

Kirsten Dunst

as Donna Martin in Beverly Hills 90210 (2000-2010)

Score: +1

Joey Lawrence

as Dylan McKay in Beverly Hills 90210 (2000-2010)

Score: +1

Brooke Nevin

as Kelly Taylor in Beverly Hills 90210 (2000-2010)

Score: +2

Alexis Bledel

as Brenda Walsh in Beverly Hills 90210 (2000-2010)

Score: +2

Drew Fuller

as Brandon Walsh in Beverly Hills 90210 (2000-2010)

Score: 0

Rachel Blanchard

as 1990s in Which Actresses Could've Played Marcia Brady In Various Decades?

Score: +2

Nicholle Tom

as 2010s in Which Actresses Could've Played Samantha Stephens In Various Decades?

Score: +1

Blake Lively

as 2020s in Which Actresses Could've Played Samantha Stephens In Various Decades?

Score: +1

Blake Lively

as 2000s in Which Actresses Could've Played Marcia Brady In Various Decades?

Score: +1

Blake Lively

as Sabrina Spellman in Sabrina The Teenage Witch (2006-2013)

Score: +1

Dawn Wells

as 1960s in What Actresses Could've Played Blair Waldorf in Various Decades?

Score: +1

Mary Tyler Moore

as 1950s in What Actresses Could've Played Blair Waldorf in Various Decades?

Score: +1