Suggestions by @dreamingofyou

Nicholle Tom

as Stars of the Show in Wild Hearts

Score: +1

Lacey Chabert

as Stars of the Show in Wild Hearts

Score: +1

Sara Paxton

as Stars of the Show in Wild Hearts

Score: +1

Homeward Bound: The Incredible Journey OST 31. Homeward Bound

as Influences in Wild Hearts

Score: 0

Air Bud

as Influences in Wild Hearts

Score: +1

Beethoven

as Influences in Wild Hearts

Score: +1

Lassie

as Influences in Wild Hearts

Score: +1

Sarah Michelle Gellar

as Gina Kinkaid in Beverly Hills 90210 (2000-2010)

Score: +1

Carly Pope

as Brenda Walsh in Beverly Hills 90210 (2000-2010)

Score: +2

Ben Feldman

as Brandon Walsh in Beverly Hills 90210 (2000-2010)

Score: 0

Michelle Williams

as Clare Arnold in Beverly Hills 90210 (2000-2010)

Score: +2

Danielle Fishel

as Cynthia Sanders in Malcolm in The Middle (1990-1996)

Score: +1

Ben Feldman

as Justin Thompson in Party of Five (2004-2010)

Score: +1

Drew Fuller

as Jeremy Gilbert in The Vampire Diaries (1999-2007)

Score: +1

Blake Lively

as 2000s in What Actresses Could've Played Sabrina Spellman in Various Decades?

Score: +1

Matthew Fox

as Jim Walsh in Beverly Hills 90210 (2000-2010)

Score: +1

Finola Hughes

as Cindy Walsh in Beverly Hills 90210 (2000-2010)

Score: +1

Katie Holmes

as Gina Kinkaid in Beverly Hills 90210 (2000-2010)

Score: +2

Brenda Song

as Janet Sosna in Beverly Hills 90210 (2000-2010)

Score: +3

Ellen Wong

as Janet Sosna in Beverly Hills 90210 (2000-2010)

Score: +2