Suggestions by @dominicsuggs

Lady Gaga

as Diane Dane in That Thing You Do (Reboot)

Score: +1

Keke Palmer

as The Chantrellines in That Thing You Do (Reboot)

Score: +1

Janelle Monáe

as The Chantrellines in That Thing You Do (Reboot)

Score: +1

Beyoncé

as The Chantrellines in That Thing You Do (Reboot)

Score: +1

Keanu Reeves

as Scott "Wolfman" Pell in That Thing You Do (Reboot)

Score: +1

LaKeith Stanfield

as Lamarr in That Thing You Do (Reboot)

Score: +1

Danny Glover

as Del Paxton in That Thing You Do (Reboot)

Score: +1

Ethan Embry

as Phil Horace in That Thing You Do (Reboot)

Score: +1

Johnathon Schaech

as Sol Siler in That Thing You Do (Reboot)

Score: +1

Steve Zahn

as Troy Chesterfield in That Thing You Do (Reboot)

Score: +1

Tom Everett Scott

as Mr. Patterson in That Thing You Do (Reboot)

Score: +1

Dylan Sprouse

as Chad in That Thing You Do (Reboot)

Score: -1

Stanley Tucci

as Freddy Fredrickson in That Thing You Do (Reboot)

Score: +1

Céline Dion

as Diane Dane in That Thing You Do (Reboot)

Score: -1

Margot Robbie

as Tina in That Thing You Do (Reboot)

Score: +1

Lily Collins

as Faye in That Thing You Do (Reboot)

Score: 0

Joseph Quinn

as Leonard "Lenny" Haise in That Thing You Do (Reboot)

Score: +1

Thomas Brody

as T.B Player in That Thing You Do (Reboot)

Score: +1

Aaron Taylor-Johnson

as James "Jimmy" Mattingly II in That Thing You Do (Reboot)

Score: +1

Patrick Wilson

as Mr. White in That Thing You Do (Reboot)

Score: +1