Suggestions by @dominicsuggs

Jack Black

as Pintel in Pirates of the Caribbean (Reboot)

Score: +1

Martin Klebba

as Marty in Pirates of the Caribbean (Reboot)

Score: +3

Simon Pegg

as Joshamee Gibbs in Pirates of the Caribbean (Reboot)

Score: +1

Theo James

as James Norrington in Pirates of the Caribbean (Reboot)

Score: +2

Gary Oldman

as Governor Weatherby Swann in Pirates of the Caribbean (Reboot)

Score: +2

Mads Mikkelsen

as Captain Hector Barbossa in Pirates of the Caribbean (Reboot)

Score: +2

Sophie Turner

as Elizabeth Swann in Pirates of the Caribbean (Reboot)

Score: +1

Hero Fiennes Tiffin

as Will Turner in Pirates of the Caribbean (Reboot)

Score: +2

Timothée Chalamet

as Captain Jack Sparrow in Pirates of the Caribbean (Reboot)

Score: +2

Hailee Steinfeld

as Kate Bishop in Ghost Rider

Score: +1

Iman Vellani

as Kamala Khan in Ghost Rider

Score: +1

Sadie Sink

as Lisa in Ghost Rider

Score: +1

Benicio del Toro

as Eli Morrow in Ghost Rider

Score: +1

Diego Luna

as Mephisto in Ghost Rider

Score: +1

Xolo Maridueña

as Gabe Reyes in Ghost Rider

Score: +1

Keanu Reeves

as Johnny Blaze in Ghost Rider

Score: 0

Jake T. Austin

as Robbie Reyes in Ghost Rider

Score: +1

Colin Hanks

as Mr. White in That Thing You Do (Reboot)

Score: +1

Tom Everett Scott

as Mr. White in That Thing You Do (Reboot)

Score: +1

Tanner Buchanan

as Chad in That Thing You Do (Reboot)

Score: +1