Suggestions by @cottonswabs

Catherine O'Hara

as Franny in Practical Magic

Score: +1

Catherine Keener

as Jet in Practical Magic

Score: +2

Taron Egerton

as Gary in Practical Magic

Score: +1

Dacre Montgomery

as Gary in Practical Magic

Score: +1

Dev Patel

as Gary in Practical Magic

Score: +1

Louis Partridge

as Scott in Practical Magic

Score: +1

Javon Walton

as Gideon in Practical Magic

Score: -1

Casey Simpson

as Gideon in Practical Magic

Score: -1

Walker Scobell

as Gideon in Practical Magic

Score: +1

Ben Barnes

as Jimmy in Practical Magic

Score: +1

Kit Harington

as Ben in Practical Magic

Score: +1

Alyvia Alyn Lind

as Kylie in Practical Magic

Score: 0

Claire Holt

as Gillian in Practical Magic

Score: -1

Emerald Fennell

as Gillian in Practical Magic

Score: -2

Rachel Nichols

as Sally in Practical Magic

Score: -2

Lucas Till

as Michael in Practical Magic

Score: +1

Violet Brinson

as Antonia in Practical Magic

Score: +1

Isabella Sermon

as Kylie in Practical Magic

Score: -1

Blake Lively

as Gillian in Practical Magic

Score: -2

Krysten Ritter

as Sally in Practical Magic

Score: +1