Suggestions by @cottonswabs

Anne Winters

as Diana in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: +1

Hero Fiennes Tiffin

as Nick in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: -1

Paris Berelc

as Debra in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: +1

Nico Parker

as Laurel in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: +1

Rowan Blanchard

as Laurel in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: -1

Kerri Medders

as Susan in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: +1

Kyla Kenedy

as Susan in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: -1

Lauren Tsai

as Melanie in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: +1

Jake Austin Walker

as Adam in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: +1

Camila Morrone

as Faye in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: +1

Tiera Skovbye

as Diana in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: -1

Olivia Holt

as Diana in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: -1

Malina Weissman

as Cassie in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: -1

Gavin Leatherwood

as Nick in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: -1

Larsen Thompson

as Antonia in The Book of Magic

Score: +1

Pierce Brosnan

as Vincent in The Book of Magic

Score: +1

Liam Neeson

as Vincent in The Book of Magic

Score: +1

Sissy Spacek

as Franny in The Book of Magic

Score: +1

Sissy Spacek

as Sally in The Book of Magic

Score: +1

Sally Field

as Jet in The Book of Magic

Score: +1