Suggestions by @cinematiccuckoo
256 suggestions
Geena Davis
as The Mother in How I Met your Mother
Score: +1
Dana Carvey
as Barney Stinson in How I Met your Mother
Score: +1
Steve Guttenberg
as Marshall Erickson in How I Met your Mother
Score: +1
Bob Saget
as Ted Mosby in How I Met your Mother
Score: +1
Andrew Lincoln
as Humphrey Bogart in American Motion Picture Story: Casablanca
Score: +2
Susan Sarandon
as The Virgin Mary in The Bible(story removed)
Score: +1
Keanu Reeves
as Jesus Christ of Nazareth in The Bible(story removed)
Score: +1
Idris Elba
as Jesus Christ of Nazareth in The Bible(story removed)
Score: +1
Kevin Alejandro
as Jesus Christ of Nazareth in The Bible(story removed)
Score: +1
Kevin Alves
as Jesus Christ of Nazareth in The Bible(story removed)
Score: +1
Jamie Bell
as Jimmy Olson in Superman Begins (2006)(story private)
Score: +1
Brian Cox
as Jor-El in Superman Begins (2006)(story private)
Score: +1
Paul Bettany
as Brainiac in Superman Begins (2006)(story private)
Score: +1
Claire Danes
as Lois Lane in Superman Begins (2006)(story private)
Score: +1
Dominic Cooper
as Clark Kent in Superman Begins (2006)(story private)
Score: +1
Edmund Lowe
as Oswald Cobblepot in Gotham (1930s)
Score: -1
Steve Guttenberg
as John Romita Sr.. in Timely
Score: +1
Darren Criss
as John Romita Jr. in Timely
Score: +1
Simon Helberg
as Joe Simon in Timely
Score: +1
George E. Stone
as Salvatore Maroni in Gotham (1930s)
Score: +1