Suggestions by @cinematiccuckoo
256 suggestions
Dan Butler
as James Cagney in Frasier Actors as Old Hollywood Stars
Score: +1
Edward Hibbert
as Claude Rains in Frasier Actors as Old Hollywood Stars
Score: +1
David Hyde Pierce
as Buster Keaton in Frasier Actors as Old Hollywood Stars
Score: +1
Kelsey Grammer
as Orson Welles in Frasier Actors as Old Hollywood Stars
Score: +1
Jamie Bell
as Charlie Chaplin in The Story of Hollywood (story private)
Score: +1
David Harbour
as Amos Decker in Amos Decker series
Score: +2
Rainn Wilson
as Mario in Super Mario Bros. (2022)(story removed)
Score: 0
Kenan Thompson
as David Taylor Parody in The Righteous Gemstones potential guest stars
Score: +4
B. J. Novak
as Julius and Philip Epstein in American Motion Picture Story: Casablanca
Score: +1
Hafþór Júlíus Björnsson
as Julius and Philip Epstein in American Motion Picture Story: Casablanca
Score: +1
Kim Novak
as Julius and Philip Epstein in American Motion Picture Story: Casablanca
Score: +1
Steve Harris
as Dooley Wilson in American Motion Picture Story: Casablanca
Score: +1
Chris Barrie
as Sidney Greenstreet in American Motion Picture Story: Casablanca
Score: +1
Lauren German
as Ingrid Bergman in American Motion Picture Story: Casablanca
Score: +1
Jim Norton
as Corrado John Soprano Jr. in The Many Saints of Newark (Alternate Casting)(story private)
Score: +1
Jim Norton
as Corrado John Soprano Jr. in The Many Saints of Newark (Alternate Casting)(story private)
Score: +1
Vincent Piazza
as Giovanni Francis Soprano in The Many Saints of Newark (Alternate Casting)(story private)
Score: +1
David Ogden Stiers
as Ebenezer Scrooge in Disney's A Christmas Carol (1991)
Score: +4
Donald Sutherland
as Frankenstein in Hotel Transylvania (1982)
Score: +3
Jerry Stiller
as Wayne in Hotel Transylvania (1982)
Score: +2