Suggestions by @caitlinfrost

Princess Cadance

as Lovely Leopard in Fictional Characters by Webkinz Pet

Score: +1

Mowgli

as Panther in Fictional Characters by Webkinz Pet

Score: +3

Rubeus Hagrid

as Magical Hippogriff in Fictional Characters by Webkinz Pet

Score: +2

Helga Hufflepuff

as Badger in Fictional Characters by Webkinz Pet

Score: +2

Kisa Sohma

as Majestic Tiger in Fictional Characters by Webkinz Pet

Score: +1

Newt Scamander

as Thunderbird in Fictional Characters by Webkinz Pet

Score: +1

Moana

as Rooster in Fictional Characters by Webkinz Pet

Score: +1

Te Ka

as Lava Dragon in Fictional Characters by Webkinz Pet

Score: +1

Morwenna Banks

as Elizabeth I in Actors by Historical Figures They've Played

Score: +1

Mai (Avatar: The Last Airbender)

as Maud Pie in My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, if fictional characters made it

Score: +2

The Boulder

as Iron Will in My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, if fictional characters made it

Score: +2

Saruman

as Best Literary/Book Villain in Best And Worst Of Villains

Score: +1

Sasha (Warrior Cats)

as Colorpoint in Fictional Cats By Coat Color

Score: +1

Karen the cat

as Colorpoint in Fictional Cats By Coat Color

Score: +1

Cake the Cat

as Red- Bicolor in Fictional Cats By Coat Color

Score: +1

Morris the Cat

as Red in Fictional Cats By Coat Color

Score: +1

Huckle Cat

as Tortoiseshell/Calico in Fictional Cats By Coat Color

Score: +2

Doctor Mid-Nite (Charles McNider)

as Blind in Canonically Disabled Characters

Score: +2

Grizabella

as Mobility Impairment in Canonically Disabled Characters

Score: +1

Rie Yoshizawa

as Mary I in Actors who have played English monarchs

Score: +2