Suggestions by @burnttoaststudios
5,776 suggestions
John Cryer
as Tad Ducksworth in In Search of a Midnight Kiss
Score: -1
Pete Davidson
as Dave Ducksworth in In Search of a Midnight Kiss
Score: +2
Lindsey Morgan
as Kelly Butterstain in In Search of a Midnight Kiss
Score: +2
Malu Trevejo
as Melina Butterstain in In Search of a Midnight Kiss
Score: +1
Salma Hayek Pinault
as Gloria Butterstain in In Search of a Midnight Kiss
Score: +3
Danny DeVito
as Reginald Butterstain in In Search of a Midnight Kiss
Score: +1
Olivia Rodrigo
as Allie in In Search of a Midnight Kiss
Score: +1
Selena Gomez
as Maria in In Search of a Midnight Kiss
Score: +1
Andre Kim
as Bui in In Search of a Midnight Kiss
Score: +2
Natalie Martinez
as Vivian in In Search of a Midnight Kiss
Score: +3
Trevor Jackson
as Jacob in In Search of a Midnight Kiss
Score: +1
Shay Mitchell
as Min in In Search of a Midnight Kiss
Score: +2
François Arnaud
as Wilson in In Search of a Midnight Kiss
Score: +2
Malu Trevejo
as Barbara Gordon in Batman (story private)
Score: +1
Dianna Agron
as Chloe Sullivan in Batman (story private)
Score: +1
Camille Hyde
as Tabitha Galavan in Batman (story private)
Score: +1
Monica Raymund
as Reneè Montoya in Batman (story private)
Score: +1
Olivia Ponton
as Carrie Kelley in Batman (story private)
Score: +1
Kat Graham
as Leslie Thompkins in Batman (story private)
Score: +1
Nina Dobrev
as Lois Lane in Batman (story private)
Score: +1