Suggestions by @burnttoaststudios

Helen Mirren

as Lorraine Simson in In Search of a Midnight Kiss

Score: +1

Billy Dee Williams

as Marty Smithers in In Search of a Midnight Kiss

Score: +3

Jacob Batalon

as Karl Wong Jr in In Search of a Midnight Kiss

Score: +2

Charles Melton

as Kade Henderson in In Search of a Midnight Kiss

Score: +1

Lili Reinhart

as Jenny Kapowski in In Search of a Midnight Kiss

Score: +1

Camila Mendes

as Tori Gomez in In Search of a Midnight Kiss

Score: +1

Emily Ratajkowski

as Aries Mischef in In Search of a Midnight Kiss

Score: +1

Maia Mitchell

as Mabel Smith in In Search of a Midnight Kiss

Score: +1

Darren Criss

as Maurice Michell in In Search of a Midnight Kiss

Score: +1

Tyler Posey

as Kai Stone in In Search of a Midnight Kiss

Score: +1

Peyton Elizabeth Lee

as Jessie in In Search of a Midnight Kiss

Score: +1

Siena Agudong

as Nick in In Search of a Midnight Kiss

Score: +2

Sofia Wylie

as Sierra Tate in In Search of a Midnight Kiss

Score: +1

Jenna Coleman

as Miss Cora Dawson in In Search of a Midnight Kiss

Score: +1

Olivia Holt

as Cheyenne Kimball in In Search of a Midnight Kiss

Score: +1

Chris Colfer

as Luke Kimball in In Search of a Midnight Kiss

Score: +1

Jordan Alexander

as Natalia Holt in In Search of a Midnight Kiss

Score: +2

Keiynan Lonsdale

as Marcus Holt in In Search of a Midnight Kiss

Score: +2

Kristanna Loken

as Margaret Ducksworth in In Search of a Midnight Kiss

Score: +1

Jon Cryer

as Tad Ducksworth in In Search of a Midnight Kiss

Score: +1