Suggestions by @brayy

Rooney Mara

as Pepper in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Fran Drescher

as Shachath in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Bruce Campbell

as Leigh Emerson in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Nikolaj Coster-Waldau

as Johnny Morgan in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Aubrey Plaza

as Shelley in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Eiza González

as Teresa Morrison in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Ellen Burstyn

as Mother Claudia in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Christine Baranski

as Sister Jude in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Stephen Lang

as Dr. Arthur Arden in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Yara Shahidi

as Alma Walker in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Katherine Langford

as Grace Bertrand in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Sasha Pieterse

as Sister Mary Eunice in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: 0

Leslie Odom Jr.

as Monsignor Timothy Howard in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Taylor Schilling

as Wendy Peyser in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Emmy Rossum

as Lana Winters in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Will Poulter

as Dr. Oliver Thredson in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

mgk

as Leo Morrison in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Kevin Alves

as Kit Walker in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +2

Amy Sedaris

as Marcy in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Matt Smith

as Charles Montgomery in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1