Suggestions by @brayy

Elisabeth Moss

as Bette & Dot Tattler in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Brandon Routh

as Hank Foxx in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: 0

Julia Louis-Dreyfus

as Joan Ramsey in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Lauren Potter

as Nan in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Eliza Taylor

as Misty Day in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Ralph Ineson

as Spalding in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Dominique Fishback

as Queenie in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Dianna Agron

as Cordelia Goode in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Sharon Stone

as Fiona Goode in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Milo Manheim

as Luke Ramsey in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Daisy Edgar-Jones

as Kaylee in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Barbara Crampton

as Anna Leigh Leighton in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +2

Djimon Hounsou

as Papa Legba in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Ethan Cutkosky

as Kyle Spencer in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Margo Martindale

as Delphine LaLaurie in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Alex Kingston

as Myrtle Snow in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Violett Beane

as Madison Montgomery in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Liv Hewson

as Zoe Benson in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +2

Danielle Deadwyler

as Marie Laveau in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1

Patrick Wilson

as The Axeman in American Horror Story: Recast

Score: +1