Suggestions by @brandonsiddall

Danny McBride

as Jerry Horne in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +1

Stanley Tucci

as Ben Horne in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +1

Toni Collette

as Sarah Palmer in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +2

Patrick Wilson

as Leland Palmer in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +3

Taylor Richardson

as Donna Hayward in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +1

Elijah Richardson

as James Hurley in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +1

Connor Swindells

as Andy Brennan in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +2

Stephen Root

as Pete Martell in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +1

Chace Crawford

as Sheriff Truman in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +2

Daniel Radcliffe

as Agent Dale Cooper in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +1

Peyton List

as Laura Palmer in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +3

Eric Wareheim

as Elmer in Twin Peaks: The End

Score: +1

Michael Cera

as Wally Brando in Twin Peaks: The End

Score: +1

Mädchen Amick

as Shelly Johnson in Twin Peaks: The End

Score: +1

Heather Graham

as Annie Blackburn in Twin Peaks: The End

Score: +1

David Patrick Kelly

as Jerry Horne in Twin Peaks: The End

Score: +1

Richard Beymer

as Ben Horne in Twin Peaks: The End

Score: +1

King Krule

as Issac in Twin Peaks: The End

Score: +1

Tim Rozon

as Randy Chalfont in Twin Peaks: The End

Score: +1

Sheryl Lee

as Laura Palmer in Twin Peaks: The End

Score: +2