Suggestions by @brandonsiddall

Michael Spears

as Hawk in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +2

Corbin Bernsen

as Graham O'Brien in Doctor Who - The American Series

Score: 0

Steve McQueen

as 3rd Doctor in Doctor Who - The American Series

Score: -2

Jeff Goldblum

as 5th Doctor in Doctor Who - The American Series

Score: +6

Bradley Cooper

as Vince McMahon in Titan 2 (2024)

Score: +2

Kristen Wiig

as Linda McMahon in Titan 2 (2024)

Score: +2

Kiko Mizuhara

as Josie Packard in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +2

Kevin James

as Mike in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +1

Sophie Turner

as Annie Blackburn in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +2

Victoria Smurfit

as Norma Jennings in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +1

Laura Rogers

as Nadine Hurley in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +2

Michelle Monaghan

as Log Lady in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +1

Dennis Haysbert

as Ed Hurley in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +2

Eliot Salt

as Lucy Moran in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +1

Finn Wolfhard

as Bobby Briggs in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +1

Dacre Montgomery

as Leo Johnson in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +2

Bella Thorne

as Shelly Johnson in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +2

Pancho Moler

as The Arm in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +2

Stephen Ure

as Bob in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +1

Merit Leighton

as Audrey Horne in Twin Peaks: The Remake

Score: +1