Suggestions by @blondead

Froy Gutierrez

as Gary Langdon / Dan Mitchell in SCARY TALES(story removed)

Score: +1

Emma Roberts

as Dana Turner / Courtney Mancini in SCARY TALES(story removed)

Score: +1

Dyllón Burnside

as Tom Myers / Devante Deon in SCARY TALES(story removed)

Score: +1

Maya Hawke

as Emma Lyons / Sarah MacFarlane in SCARY TALES(story removed)

Score: +1

Sofia Wylie

as Kayla Nicholas in SCARY TALES(story removed)

Score: +1

Storm Reid

as Liah Jackson in SCARY TALES(story removed)

Score: +1

Iris Apatow

as Marsha Strode in SCARY TALES(story removed)

Score: +1

Sadie Sink

as Penny Lincoln in SCARY TALES(story removed)

Score: +1

Bill Skarsgård

as Chainsaw Killer in SCARY TALES(story removed)

Score: +1

Julian Hilliard

as Billy Johnson in SCARY TALES(story removed)

Score: +1

Finn Wolfhard

as Jack Michaels in SCARY TALES(story removed)

Score: +1

Jenna Ortega

as Sarah Adams in SCARY TALES(story removed)

Score: +1

Nico Greetham

as Neokalus Burr in SCARY TALES(story removed)

Score: +1

Evan Peters

as Nick Prescott in MURDER HOUSE '88(story removed)

Score: +1

Froy Gutierrez

as Gary Langdon / Dan Mitchell in MURDER HOUSE '88(story removed)

Score: +1

Emma Roberts

as Dana Loomis / Courtney Mancini in MURDER HOUSE '88(story removed)

Score: +1

Dyllón Burnside

as Tom Myers / Devante Deon in MURDER HOUSE '88(story removed)

Score: +1

Maya Hawke

as Emma Lyons / Sarah MacFarlane in MURDER HOUSE '88(story removed)

Score: +1

Mckenna Grace

as Grady Twins in The Shining (2023)(story removed)

Score: -1

Sydney Sweeney

as Young (and Old) Woman in Bath in The Shining (2023)(story removed)

Score: +3