Suggestions by @blondead

John Carroll Lynch

as Elias Voorhees in Crystal Lake: The Series (2022)(story removed)

Score: +2

Xolo Maridueña

as Patrick Benson in Crystal Lake: The Series (2022)(story removed)

Score: +1

David Harbour

as Tom Hawkins in Crystal Lake: The Series (2022)(story removed)

Score: +3

Alan Ritchson

as Jason Voorhees in Crystal Lake: The Series (2022)(story removed)

Score: 0

Emma Roberts

as Erin Lodge in Crystal Lake: The Series (2022)(story removed)

Score: +3

Alexa Demie

as Laney Krueger in Crystal Lake: The Series (2022)(story removed)

Score: +1

Jacob Elordi

as Luke Johnson in Crystal Lake: The Series (2022)(story removed)

Score: +1

Hunter Schafer

as Lola Michaels in Crystal Lake: The Series (2022)(story removed)

Score: +1

Benjamin Wadsworth

as Nick Benson in Crystal Lake: The Series (2022)(story removed)

Score: +1

Jenna Ortega

as Maxine Krueger / Young Gale Lopez in Crystal Lake: The Series (2022)(story removed)

Score: +5

Caleb McLaughlin

as Brendan Krueger in SCARY TALES(story removed)

Score: +1

Alexa Demie

as Roxanne Valentine in SCARY TALES(story removed)

Score: +1

Maika Monroe

as Amber James in SCARY TALES(story removed)

Score: +1

Talia Ryder

as Kat Manson in SCARY TALES(story removed)

Score: +1

Penn Badgley

as The Butcher in SCARY TALES(story removed)

Score: +1

Joe Keery

as Jeff Nelson in SCARY TALES(story removed)

Score: +1

Sydney Sweeney

as Megan Tilly in SCARY TALES(story removed)

Score: +1

Jack Quaid

as The Driller Killer in SCARY TALES(story removed)

Score: +1

Darren Criss

as Jim Cox in SCARY TALES(story removed)

Score: +1

Evan Peters

as Nick Prescott in SCARY TALES(story removed)

Score: +1