Suggestions by @amazonprince

Brigitte Nielsen

as Starfire in The New Teen Titans (1970s)

Score: +1

Sônia Braga

as Blackfire in The New Teen Titans (1970s)

Score: +1

Maribel Guardia

as Blackfire in The New Teen Titans (1970s)

Score: -1

Raquel Welch

as Blackfire in The New Teen Titans (1970s)

Score: +1

Ron Howard

as The Kid Flash in The New Teen Titans (1970s)

Score: +1

Mickey Rooney

as Beast-Boy/The Changeling in The New Teen Titans (1970s)

Score: +1

Persis Khambatta

as Raven in The New Teen Titans (1970s)

Score: +1

Jim Brown

as Cyborg in The New Teen Titans (1970s)

Score: +1

Iris Chacón Tapia

as Starfire in The New Teen Titans (1970s)

Score: -1

Marie Osmond

as Wonder Girl in The New Teen Titans (1970s)

Score: +1

Burt Ward

as Robin/Nightwing in The New Teen Titans (1970s)

Score: +1

Kristen Stewart

as Scandal Savage in Anxious, Secure, Avoidant, Discordant

Score: +2

Emily Blunt

as Cheetah in DC Rogues Gallery

Score: +1

Tom Cruise

as The Fiddler in DC Rogues Gallery

Score: +2

Lera Abova

as Strife in DC Rogues Gallery

Score: +1

Dennis Haysbert

as Darkseid in DC Rogues Gallery

Score: +1

Grant Morrison

as Brainiac in DC Rogues Gallery

Score: +1

Wes Bentley

as The Joker in DC Rogues Gallery

Score: +1

Leonardo DiCaprio

as The Joker in DC Rogues Gallery

Score: +1

Jharrel Jerome

as Black Manta in DC Rogues Gallery

Score: +3