Suggestions by @amazonprince

Halle Berry

as Storm in The Uncanny X-Men & The New Titans

Score: +1

Tye Sheridan

as Cyclops in The Uncanny X-Men & The New Titans

Score: +1

James Marsden

as Cyclops in The Uncanny X-Men & The New Titans

Score: +1

Hugh Jackman

as Wolverine in The Uncanny X-Men & The New Titans

Score: +1

Sylvester Stallone

as Stakar Ogard, the Ravager in The Uncanny X-Men & The New Titans

Score: +1

Famke Janssen

as Dark Phoenix in The Uncanny X-Men & The New Titans

Score: +1

Sophie Turner

as Dark Phoenix in The Uncanny X-Men & The New Titans

Score: -1

Esai Morales

as Deathstroke, the Terminator in The Uncanny X-Men & The New Titans

Score: +1

Joe Manganiello

as Deathstroke, the Terminator in The Uncanny X-Men & The New Titans

Score: +1

Ray Porter

as Darkseid in The Uncanny X-Men & The New Titans

Score: +1

Eric Bana

as Deathstroke, the Terminator in DC Rogues Gallery

Score: +2

Tim Curry

as Trigon in The New Teen Titans (1970s)

Score: +1

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles

as Troogar in The New Teen Titans (1970s)

Score: +1

Charlie the Velociraptor

as Troogar in The New Teen Titans (1970s)

Score: -1

Predator Roars

as Troogar in The New Teen Titans (1970s)

Score: -1

Xenomorph Warrior

as Troogar in The New Teen Titans (1970s)

Score: -1

The Toxic Avenger

as Troogar in The New Teen Titans (1970s)

Score: -1

Island of the Fishmen

as Troogar in The New Teen Titans (1970s)

Score: -1

Kurt Russell

as Deathstroke in The Other History of the DC Universe (1978)

Score: +1

Kurt Russell

as Slade in The New Teen Titans (1970s)

Score: +1