Suggestions by @agent39

Emily Blunt

as Judith in Judith

Score: +1

Richard Dean Anderson

as Dr. Franklin Storm in The Fantastic Four

Score: +7

John Lithgow

as Dr. Franklin Storm in The Fantastic Four

Score: +1

Adam Driver

as Manasseh of Judah in The Bible

Score: +1

Kenneth Branagh

as Hezekiah in The Bible

Score: +1

Matthew McConaughey

as Boaz in The Bible

Score: 0

Ruth Wilson

as Miriam in The Bible

Score: +4

Clark Gregg

as Elisha in The Bible

Score: +2

Evangeline Lilly

as Ruth in The Bible

Score: +2

Paul Rudd

as Gideon in The Bible

Score: +2

Liam Hemsworth

as Joseph of Nazareth in The Bible

Score: +4

Cybill Shepherd

as Naomi in The Bible

Score: -1

Gina Rodriguez

as Leah in The Bible

Score: -2

David Harbour

as Moses in The Bible

Score: -5

Sean Astin

as Lazarus in The Bible

Score: -2

Arnold Schwarzenegger

as Goliath in The Bible

Score: +5

Gillian Anderson

as Deborah in The Bible

Score: -1

Aidan Turner

as Nebuchadnezzar in The Bible

Score: 0

Donnie Yen

as The Magi in The Bible

Score: +3

Andrew Lincoln

as Noah in The Bible

Score: -4