Suggestions by @adamatc

Blake Jenner

as Murray Babich in Cop Land (2023)

Score: +2

Julianne Nicholson

as Rose Donlan in Cop Land (2023)

Score: +1

Garrett Hedlund

as Joey Randone in Cop Land (2023)

Score: +1

Boyd Holbrook

as Joey Randone in Cop Land (2023)

Score: +1

Kevin Bacon

as Moe Tilden in Cop Land (2023)

Score: +1

Joel Edgerton

as Moe Tilden in Cop Land (2023)

Score: +1

Woody Harrelson

as Ray Donlan in Cop Land (2023)

Score: +4

Michael Shannon

as Ray Donlan in Cop Land (2023)

Score: +1

Keanu Reeves

as Sheriff Freddy Henlin in Cop Land (2023)

Score: +3

David Bowie

as Icabod Crane in Sleepy Hollow (1989)

Score: +1

Sacha Baron Cohen

as Buster Keaton in Buster Keaton: The Great Stone Face.

Score: 0

Tobey Maguire

as Charlie Chaplin in Buster Keaton: The Great Stone Face.

Score: +2

Ricardo Montalban

as Sallah in Raiders of the Lost Ark (1951)

Score: +1

James Mason

as René Belloq in Raiders of the Lost Ark (1951)

Score: +3

Kirk Douglas

as Indiana Jones in Raiders of the Lost Ark (1951)

Score: +2

Jane Russell

as Marion Ravenwood in Raiders of the Lost Ark (1951)

Score: +2

Robert Mitchum

as Indiana Jones in Raiders of the Lost Ark (1951)

Score: +3

Shia LaBeouf

as Chris Taylor in Platoon (2006)

Score: +3

Troian Bellisario

as Gale Weathers in Scream (2022)

Score: +2