Suggestions by @adamatc

Saoirse Ronan

as Shannon Christie in Far and Away (2020s Cast)

Score: +3

Domhnall Gleeson

as Joseph Donnelly in Far and Away (2020s Cast)

Score: 0

Meghann Fahy

as Michelle Pfeiffer in Actor BioPics

Score: +5

Meghann Fahy

as Michelle Pfeiffer in Celebrities Biopics

Score: +3

Meghann Fahy

as Michelle Pfeiffer in Biopics for famous women

Score: +4

Ariel Winter

as Stephanie in The Wrestler (TV Show)

Score: +1

Josh Hartnett

as Randy 'The Ram' Robinson in The Wrestler (TV Show)

Score: +2

Bobby Moynihan

as Peter Venkman in Almost Cast: Ghostbusters

Score: +3

Joanna Gleason

as Grace in Beau Is Afraid: 2000s Edition

Score: +1

William H. Macy

as Roger in Beau Is Afraid: 2000s Edition

Score: +3

Julianne Moore

as Mona Wassermann in Beau Is Afraid: 2000s Edition

Score: +1

Jim Carrey

as Beau Wassermann in Beau Is Afraid: 2000s Edition

Score: +1

Ana de Armas

as Virginia "Gin" Baker in Entrapment

Score: +2

Kevin Costner

as Robert "Mac" MacDougal in Entrapment

Score: +1

Naomi Scott

as Marion Ravenwood in Almost Cast: Raiders of the Lost Ark

Score: +2

Chris Evans

as John Boy in The Nice Guys (2006)

Score: +1

Jessica Biel

as Amelia Kuttner in The Nice Guys (2006)

Score: +2