Suggestions by @186fleetstreet

Dalen Spratt

as John Grey in Nancy Drew: Last Train to Blue Moon Canyon

Score: +1

Aden Young

as Professor Charles Smith in True Fear: Forsaken Souls Trilogy

Score: +1

James McCaffrey

as Edgar Allan Poe in Chronicles of the Imaginarium Geographica

Score: +1

Timothy Omundson

as Edgar Allan Poe in Chronicles of the Imaginarium Geographica

Score: +1

Sean Durrie

as Chase Relerford in Nancy Drew: Trail of the Twister

Score: +1

Matthew Porretta

as P.G. Krolmeister in Nancy Drew: Trail of the Twister

Score: +1

Lance Reddick

as Sergeant Mac Ramsay in Nancy Drew: The Final Scene

Score: +1

Tim Sutton

as Emmett in Kathy Rain: A Detective is Born

Score: +1

Mr. T

as Tik Tok in Emerald City Confidential

Score: +1

George MacKay

as Billy Hope in Outlast Trinity

Score: +1

Leslie Jordan

as Hans Voralberg in Syberia

Score: +4

Brad Dourif

as Doctor Trager in Outlast Trinity

Score: +1

Quinton Boisclar

as The Walrider in Outlast Trinity

Score: +1

Reba McEntire

as Emily Griffen in Nancy Drew: Ghost Dogs of Moon Lake

Score: +1

Cillian Murphy

as Eddie Gluskin in Outlast Trinity

Score: +2

Hafþór Júlíus Björnsson

as Chris Walker in Outlast Trinity

Score: +2

John Goodman

as Sullivan Knoth in Outlast Trinity

Score: +1

Rupert Friend

as Dylan Carter in Nancy Drew: Tomb of the Lost Queen

Score: +1

John Carroll Lynch

as Father Martin in Outlast Trinity

Score: +1

Brian Dietzen

as Blake Langermann in Outlast Trinity

Score: +1