Suggestions by @186fleetstreet

Tahmoh Penikett

as Chris Walker in Outlast Trinity

Score: +1

Aleks Paunovic

as Chris Walker in Outlast Trinity

Score: +1

Tom Ellis

as Jeremy Blaire in Outlast Trinity

Score: +1

David Harbour

as Father Martin in Outlast Trinity

Score: -1

Shawn Baichoo

as The Realtor in True Fear: Forsaken Souls Trilogy

Score: +1

F. Murray Abraham

as Rudolf Wernicke in Outlast Trinity

Score: +1

Dev Patel

as Young Nemo in Chronicles of the Imaginarium Geographica

Score: +2

Ty Olsson

as Chris Walker in Outlast Trinity

Score: 0

Samuel Barnett

as Waylon Park in Outlast Trinity

Score: 0

Tilda Swinton

as Val in Outlast Trinity

Score: +2

Rupert Friend

as Miles Upshur in Outlast Trinity

Score: +1

Hunter Schafer

as Val in Outlast Trinity

Score: +2

Doug Jones

as The Walrider in Outlast Trinity

Score: 0

Sarah Sokolovic

as Samantha Quick in Nancy Drew: The Phantom of Venice

Score: +1

Sarah Sokolovic

as Bridget Shaw in Nancy Drew: The Silent Spy

Score: +1

Leslie Odom Jr.

as Jeff Akers in Nancy Drew: Ghost Dogs of Moon Lake

Score: +1

Leslie Odom Jr.

as The Detective in True Fear: Forsaken Souls Trilogy

Score: +1

Rupert Friend

as The Journalist in True Fear: Forsaken Souls Trilogy

Score: +1

Nick Groff

as The Journalist in True Fear: Forsaken Souls Trilogy

Score: +1

Donald Faison

as The Detective in True Fear: Forsaken Souls Trilogy

Score: +1