Skip to main content

Menu

Content

Stories Talent Discover Topics Trailers Showtimes

Community

Fan Cast News Forums Polls myCast Show Community

The fan casting platform. Cast your favorite talent in movies, TV shows, and more.

Powered by

Browse

Stories
Talent
Tags
Community

Company

About
Fan Cast News
Contact
Privacy Policy
Terms of Use

Community

Forums
Add a Story
Help & FAQ

© 2026 myCast.io. All rights reserved.

/

Penny (American Girl) Fan Casting | myCast.io

Fan Casting
Talent
Penny (American Girl)

Penny (American Girl)

Penny (American Girl)

Age: 34

born September 1, 1991

female28 suggestions0 votes

About More Photos

Related Talent

Steps High

Steps High

12 roles in common

Felicity Merriman

Felicity Merriman

10 roles in common

Patriot (American Girl)

Patriot (American Girl)

10 roles in common

Georgia (American Girl)

Georgia (American Girl)

10 roles in common

Hollyhock (American Girl)

Hollyhock (American Girl)

9 roles in common

Picasso (American Girl)

Picasso (American Girl)

9 roles in common

Martha Merriman

Martha Merriman

8 roles in common

Cochon (American Girl)

Cochon (American Girl)

8 roles in common

Sprocket (American Girl)

Sprocket (American Girl)

7 roles in common

Mele (American Girl)

Mele (American Girl)

7 roles in common

Jackson (American Girl)

Jackson (American Girl)

7 roles in common

Grace (American Girl)

Grace (American Girl)

7 roles in common

Jiggy Nye

Jiggy Nye

7 roles in common

William Merriman

William Merriman

7 roles in common

Rose (American Girl: Felicity Merriman)

Rose (American Girl: Felicity Merriman)

7 roles in common

Frances Manderly

Frances Manderly

7 roles in common

Tatlo (American Girl)

Tatlo (American Girl)

6 roles in common

The Nokk (Frozen 2)

The Nokk (Frozen 2)

6 roles in common

Annabelle Cole

Annabelle Cole

6 roles in common

Posie the Lamb

Posie the Lamb

6 roles in common

Top Casting Suggestions

Penny (American Girl) has been suggested to play 28 roles. Click below to see other actors suggested for each role, and vote for who you think would play the role best.

Top Voted Newest First Oldest First

Penny (American Girl)

as

Virginia

in

Fictional Characters by US State

Voters (4)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

Virginia

Virginia

Penny (American Girl)

as

American Girl Dolls

in

All Fictional Characters Sorted by Media

Voters (3)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

American Girl Dolls

American Girl Dolls

Penny (American Girl)

as

Mothers

in

Fictional female characters (Canon and my OCs)

Voters (2)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

Mothers

Mothers

Penny (American Girl)

as

The Bus Came Back

in

Sort by Tropes

Voters (2)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

The Bus Came Back

The Bus Came Back

Penny (American Girl)

as

Horse

in

Fictional animals by species

Voters (2)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

Horse

Horse

Penny (American Girl)

as

Loyal Animal Companion

in

Sort by Tropes

Voters (2)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

Loyal Animal Companion

Loyal Animal Companion

Penny (American Girl)

as

Non-Human Sidekick

in

Sort by Tropes

Voters (2)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

Non-Human Sidekick

Non-Human Sidekick

Penny (American Girl)

as

Mothers

in

Fictional Character as Parents Face Claims

Voters (2)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

Mothers

Mothers

Penny (American Girl)

as

Movies

in

American Girl Sorting

Voters (2)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

Movies

Movies

Penny (American Girl)

as

Only the Chosen May Ride

in

Sort by Tropes

Voters (2)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

Only the Chosen May Ride

Only the Chosen May Ride

Penny (American Girl)

as

Felicity Merriman + Elizabeth Cole

in

American Girl Sorting

Voters (1)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

Felicity Merriman + Elizabeth Cole

Felicity Merriman + Elizabeth Cole

Penny (American Girl)

as

1770s

in

Characters Sorted by Time Period

Voters (1)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

1770s

1770s

Penny (American Girl)

as

Moody Mount

in

Sort by Tropes

Voters (1)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

Moody Mount

Moody Mount

Penny (American Girl)

as

Penelope

in

Characters by Name but I'm Excruciatingly Thorough

Voters (1)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

Penelope

Penelope

Penny (American Girl)

as

Pets and Animals

in

American Girl Sorting

Voters (1)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

Pets and Animals

Pets and Animals

Penny (American Girl)

as

American (United States)

in

Fictional Character Heritage

Voters (1)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

American (United States)

American (United States)

Penny (American Girl)

as

Wild Type

in

Fictional Characters by Sonic Type

Voters (1)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

Wild Type

Wild Type

Penny (American Girl)

as

Meaningful Name

in

Sort by Tropes

Voters (1)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

Meaningful Name

Meaningful Name

Penny (American Girl)

as

Air

in

Assigning Skylanders Elements to Fictional Characters

Voters (1)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

Air

Air

Penny (American Girl)

as

1991

in

Fictional Characters Categorized by Year

Voters (1)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

1991

1991

Penny (American Girl)

as

Cool Horse

in

Sort by Tropes

Voters (1)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

Cool Horse

Cool Horse

Penny (American Girl)

as

Flying

in

Fictional Characters by Pokémon Type

Voters (1)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

Flying

Flying

Penny (American Girl)

as

Penny

in

Every Name, Every Character

Voters (1)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

Penny

Penny

Penny (American Girl)

as

Penelope

in

Sorting Characters by Name

Voters (1)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

Penelope

Penelope

Showing 1–24 of 28 suggestions