Skip to main content

Menu

Content

Stories Talent Discover Topics Trailers Showtimes

Community

Fan Cast News Forums Polls myCast Show Community

The fan casting platform. Cast your favorite talent in movies, TV shows, and more.

Powered by

Browse

Stories
Talent
Tags
Community

Company

About
Fan Cast News
Contact
Privacy Policy
Terms of Use

Community

Forums
Add a Story
Help & FAQ

© 2026 myCast.io. All rights reserved.

/

Nostalgia Critic Fan Casting | myCast.io

Fan Casting
Talent
Nostalgia Critic

Nostalgia Critic

Nostalgia Critic

male60 suggestions0 votes

About More Photos

Related Talent

Angry Video Game Nerd

Angry Video Game Nerd

26 roles in common

Rick Sanchez

Rick Sanchez

13 roles in common

Homer Simpson

Homer Simpson

12 roles in common

Deadpool (Wade Wilson)

Deadpool (Wade Wilson)

11 roles in common

Patrick Star

11 roles in common

Peter Griffin

Peter Griffin

11 roles in common

Shrek

Shrek

10 roles in common

Gadget Hackwrench

Gadget Hackwrench

9 roles in common

Walter White

Walter White

9 roles in common

Daffy Duck

Daffy Duck

9 roles in common

Donkey Kong

Donkey Kong

9 roles in common

Wario

Wario

9 roles in common

Hank Hill

Hank Hill

9 roles in common

Heavy Weapons Guy

Heavy Weapons Guy

9 roles in common

SpongeBob SquarePants

SpongeBob SquarePants

8 roles in common

Bugs Bunny

Bugs Bunny

8 roles in common

Son Goku

Son Goku

8 roles in common

Kermit the Frog

Kermit the Frog

8 roles in common

Waluigi

Waluigi

8 roles in common

Pomni (The Amazing Digital Circus)

Pomni (The Amazing Digital Circus)

8 roles in common

Top Casting Suggestions

Nostalgia Critic has been suggested to play 60 roles. Click below to see other actors suggested for each role, and vote for who you think would play the role best.

Top Voted Newest First Oldest First

Nostalgia Critic

as

The Internet

in

Best Character by Franchise

Voters (2)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

The Internet

The Internet

Nostalgia Critic

as

Ambiguously Bi

in

Sort by Tropes

Voters (2)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

Ambiguously Bi

Ambiguously Bi

Nostalgia Critic

as

Sir Swears-a-Lot

in

Characters Sorted by TV Tropes Categories

Voters (2)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

Sir Swears-a-Lot

Sir Swears-a-Lot

Nostalgia Critic

as

Worst Youtubers

in

Best & Worst of Star Wars

Voters (14)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

Worst Youtubers

Worst Youtubers

Nostalgia Critic

as

Cameos

in

Frying Nemo

Voters (4)

No voters yet.

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you! Create a free profile to:

•Add your own stories and characters
•Make casting suggestions
•Vote and comment on casting suggestions
•Add and edit talent profiles
•Post to the forums

Cameos

Cameos

Showing 49–53 of 53 suggestions