Nostalgia Critic

Top Casting Suggestions

Nostalgia Critic has been suggested to play 38 roles. Click below to see other actors suggested for each role, and vote for who you think would play the role best.

• Nostalgia Critic

  as

  What if Tim Curry hadn't left Acting? (Original)

  in

  Fanscription

  8 Yes

  0 No

  

  What if Tim Curry hadn't left Acting?

• Nostalgia Critic

  as

  What if EVERYONE WAS HERE in Secret Wars? (No. 1000!!!)

  in

  Fanscription

  9 Yes

  2 No

  

  What if EVERYONE WAS HERE in Secret Wars?

• Nostalgia Critic

  as

  Back from the Dead

  in

  Sort by Tropes

  6 Yes

  0 No

  

  Back from the Dead

• Nostalgia Critic

  as

  Who Grabs The Stones?

  in

  EVERYONE: War For The Multiverse

  5 Yes

  0 No

  

  Who Grabs The Stones?

• Nostalgia Critic

  as

  Influences

  in

  Bubble Bass Reviews

  5 Yes

  0 No

  

  Bubble Bass Reviews

• Nostalgia Critic

  as

  Mystery Science Theater 3000 (MST3K)

  in

  Most Wanted Crossovers

  7 Yes

  3 No

  

  Mystery Science Theater 3000

• Nostalgia Critic

  as

  Characters who should be in the MemeCU

  in

  Best and Worst of MemeCU

  4 Yes

  0 No

  

  Best and Worst of MemeCU

• Nostalgia Critic

  as

  Best YouTuber

  in

  The Best & The Worst

  4 Yes

  0 No

  

  The Best & The Worst

• Nostalgia Critic

  as

  Smiling Friends

  in

  If this Character was in...

  4 Yes

  0 No

  

  Smiling Friends

• Nostalgia Critic

  as

  Best

  in

  Best/Worst YouTube Critic

  5 Yes

  2 No

  

  Best/Worst YouTube Critic

• Nostalgia Critic

  as

  What if The Smiling Friends made the Multiverse happy? (Crossover)

  in

  Fanscription

  4 Yes

  1 No

  

  What if The Smiling Friends made the Multiverse happy?

• Nostalgia Critic

  as

  Sarah Jane Smith

  in

  The Worst Doctor Who Series

  3 Yes

  0 No

  

  The Worst Doctor Who Series

• Nostalgia Critic

  as

  Best Character

  in

  Best & Worst of Nostalgia Critic

  3 Yes

  0 No

  

  Best Character

• Nostalgia Critic

  as

  Smiling Friends

  in

  Most Wanted Crossovers

  3 Yes

  0 No

  

  Smiling Friends

• Nostalgia Critic

  as

  Cultural References

  in

  Smiling Friends (Season 3)

  3 Yes

  0 No

  

  Smiling Friends (Season 3)

• Nostalgia Critic

  as

  Season 28 Lineup (By Themegacaster)

  in

  MultiVersus: Assemble Your Own Season Lineup!

  3 Yes

  0 No

  

  MultiVersus: Assemble Your Own Season Lineup!

• Nostalgia Critic

  as

  AND FRIENDS (LET'S GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO)

  in

  Pooh's Adventures in Sanity

  2 Yes

  0 No

  

  Pooh's Adventures in Sanity

• Nostalgia Critic

  as

  AVGN or Nostalgia Critic

  in

  Debates

  2 Yes

  0 No

  

  Debates

• Nostalgia Critic

  as

  Cameos (Special Guests)

  in

  Learning with Pibby (•Live-Action/Animated Movie•)

  2 Yes

  0 No

  

  Learning with Pibby (•Live-Action/Animated Movie•)

• Nostalgia Critic

  as

  Youtubers

  in

  Internet Cinematic Universe

  2 Yes

  0 No

  

  Internet Cinematic Universe

• Nostalgia Critic

  as

  TomzillawasH3R3

  in

  MyCast Users' Favorite YouTube Series

  2 Yes

  0 No

  

  MyCast Users' Favorite YouTube Series

• Nostalgia Critic

  as

  What if the Care Bears all Died? (Taste the Rainbow Mothaf*cka!)

  in

  Fanscription

  2 Yes

  0 No

  

  What if the Care Bears all Died?

• Nostalgia Critic

  as

  Best YouTuber

  in

  2022 Mycast Awards

  3 Yes

  2 No

  

  2022 Mycast Awards

• Nostalgia Critic

  as

  Oogie Boogie

  in

  The Nightmare Before Christmas

  2 Yes

  1 No

  

  The Nightmare Before Christmas