Suggestions by @zephyrix

Isabela Merced

as Toralei Stripe in Monster High Live Action

Score: +1

Mădălina Bellariu Ion

as Esmeralda in Disney's The Hunchback of Notre Dame (2028)

Score: -1

Marsai Martin

as Emily in Hazbin Hotel Live Action

Score: +1

Aja Naomi King

as Sera in Hazbin Hotel Live Action

Score: +1

Jacob Tremblay

as Winnie in Cold Front

Score: +1

Asa Butterfield

as Augustine in Cold Front

Score: +1

Charlie Hunnam

as Forcas in Eloquent Counteance

Score: +1

Lily-Rose Depp

as Angelica in Eloquent Counteance

Score: +1

Alex Lawther

as Normal Guy in Elevator Hitch

Score: +1

Jack Quaid

as Co-worker in Elevator Hitch

Score: +1

Xolo Maridueña

as Protag in Elevator Hitch

Score: +1

Garance Marillier

as Manon Vacher in Dead Plate

Score: +1

Eric Bauza

as Rouxls Kaard in Undertale: The Series

Score: +1

Jennifer Hale

as Toriel in Undertale: The Series

Score: +2

Jeremy Shada

as Monster Kid in Undertale: The Series

Score: +1

Stephanie Beatriz

as Undyne in Undertale: The Series

Score: 0

Tom Kenny

as Papyrus in Undertale: The Series

Score: +2

Alex Hirsch

as Spamton in Undertale/Deltarune/UTY the series

Score: +1

Toby Fox

as Tenna in Undertale/Deltarune/UTY the series

Score: +1

Mina Sundwall

as Noelle Holiday in Undertale/Deltarune/UTY the series

Score: +1