Suggestions by @zarice2132

Sterling Knight

as Randy Van Ronson in Katy Keene

Score: +3

Lucien Laviscount

as Alexander Cabot in Katy Keene

Score: +1

Camille Hyde

as Alexandra Cabot in Katy Keene

Score: 0

Asha Bromfield

as Melody Valentine in Katy Keene

Score: +1

Hayley Law

as Valerie Brown in Katy Keene

Score: +1

Julia Chan

as Pepper Smith in Katy Keene

Score: +1

Jonny Beauchamp

as Ginger Lopez in Katy Keene

Score: +1

Ashleigh Murray

as Josie McCoy in Katy Keene

Score: +1

Lucy Hale

as Katy Keene in Katy Keene

Score: +5

Ben Affleck

as Bruce Wayne in My DC Movieverse (fancast)

Score: 0

Alexander Siddig

as Ra's al Ghul in Batman

Score: +1

Emma Stone

as Barbara Gordon in Batman

Score: +3

Kate Beckinsale

as Talia al Ghul in Batman

Score: -1

Jared Leto

as Arthur Fleck in Batman

Score: +3

Alain Delon

as Batman in Batman (1960)

Score: +6

Jason Lewis

as Aquaman in Superman Doomsday returns

Score: +1

Aaron Taylor-Johnson

as Flash in Superman Doomsday returns

Score: +1

Jaimie Alexander

as Wonder women in Superman Doomsday returns

Score: +3

Ben Affleck

as Batman in Superman Doomsday returns

Score: +5

Jennifer Connelly

as Lois lane in Superman Doomsday returns

Score: +4