Suggestions by @zamaj007

Judah Lewis

as Classmates of the gang (the yearbook duo and choir guy) in American Pie

Score: +1

Sean Kaufman

as Classmates of the gang (the yearbook duo and choir guy) in American Pie

Score: +1

Niles Fitch

as Classmates of the gang (the yearbook duo and choir guy) in American Pie

Score: +1

Logan Shroyer

as Classmates of the gang (the yearbook duo and choir guy) in American Pie

Score: +1

Matt Cornett

as Steve Stifler in American Pie

Score: +2

Daniel DiMaggio

as Chuck Sherman in American Pie

Score: +1

Gillian Jacobs

as Stifler's mom (Rebecca) in American Pie

Score: +2

Olivia Thirlby

as Stifler's mom (Rebecca) in American Pie

Score: +1

Nicholas Galitzine

as Steve Stifler in American Pie

Score: +1

Sophia Lillis

as Jessica in American Pie

Score: +1

Rain Spencer

as Vicki in American Pie

Score: +2

Cree Cicchino

as Nadia in American Pie

Score: +1

Charlie Day

as Mr. Noah Levenstein in American Pie

Score: +2

Allison Williams

as Mrs. Kayla Levenstein in American Pie

Score: 0

Allison Brie

as Mrs. Kayla Levenstein in American Pie

Score: +1

Yvonne Strahovski

as Mrs. Kayla Levenstein in American Pie

Score: +1

Rose Byrne

as Mrs. Kayla Levenstein in American Pie

Score: +2

Brittany Snow

as Mrs. Kayla Levenstein in American Pie

Score: +1

Jason Sudeikis

as Mr. Noah Levenstein in American Pie

Score: +2

Ty Burrell

as Mr. Noah Levenstein in American Pie

Score: +1