Suggestions by @zacharyrosemann

Ross Lynch

as Trent Vickers in Jeff The Killer: Jeff's Beginning

Score: +1

Patrick Dempsey

as Nate Millar in Jeff The Killer: Jeff's Beginning

Score: +1

Gerard Butler

as Roy Barnes in Jeff The Killer: Jeff's Beginning

Score: +1

Tanner Buchanan

as Troy in Jeff The Killer: Jeff's Beginning

Score: 0

Thomas Brodie-Sangster

as Keith in Jeff The Killer: Jeff's Beginning

Score: +1

Jace Norman

as Randy in Jeff The Killer: Jeff's Beginning

Score: +1

Ariel Winter

as Lilly Brown in Jeff The Killer: Jeff's Beginning

Score: +1

Evan Peters

as Liu Woods in Jeff The Killer: Jeff's Beginning

Score: +1

Timothée Chalamet

as Jeffery Woods in Jeff The Killer: Jeff's Beginning

Score: +1

Jack Dylan Grazer

as Miles in Scream

Score: +1

Miles Robbins

as Brennan in Scream

Score: +1

Asa Butterfield

as Ryan in Scream

Score: +1

Walker Scobell

as Ian in Scream

Score: +1

Jon Bernthal

as Sheriff Louis Carter in Scream

Score: +1

Anya Taylor-Joy

as Lilly Jones in Scream

Score: +1

Joey King

as Lisa in Scream

Score: +1

Finn Wolfhard

as Aaron in Scream

Score: +1

Charlie Cox

as Matt Atlas in Scream

Score: +1

Olivia Scott Welch

as Olivia Moore in Scream

Score: +1

Milo Manheim

as Owen Atlas in Scream

Score: +1