Suggestions by @zacharyleon

Vince Vaughn

as Joseph Martello in Spider-Man Brand New Day

Score: +1

Claudia Doumit

as Talia Al Ghūl in Batman: The Brave and The Bold

Score: +1

Bill Skarsgård

as Bruce Wayne in Batman: The Brave and The Bold

Score: +1

Louis Partridge

as Jason Todd in Batman: The Brave and The Bold

Score: +1

Sasha Calle

as Salina Kyle in Batman: The Brave and The Bold

Score: 0

Kyle Chandler

as Captain George Stacy in Spider-Man Brand New Day

Score: +1

Adrian Brody

as The Strange Man in Red Dead Redemption

Score: +2

Demián Bichir

as Colonel Agustin Allende in Red Dead Redemption

Score: +2

Sam Witwer

as Archer Fordham in Red Dead Redemption

Score: +2

Seth Green

as Professor Harold Macdougal in Red Dead Redemption

Score: +2

Seth Green

as Professor Harold Macdougal in Red Dead Redemption

Score: +1

Seth Green

as Professor Harold Macdougal in Red Dead Redemption

Score: +1

Ted Levine

as Edgar Ross in Red Dead Redemption

Score: +1

Joel Marsh Garland

as Deputy Eli in Red Dead Redemption

Score: +2

Bronson Webb

as Deputy Jonah in Red Dead Redemption

Score: +2

Sam Neill

as Marshall Leigh Johnson in Red Dead Redemption

Score: +2

Diane Guerrero

as Luisa Fortuna in Red Dead Redemption

Score: +3

Vanessa Kirby

as Bonnie MacFarlane in Red Dead Redemption

Score: +3

Rodrigo Santoro

as Abraham Reyes in Red Dead Redemption

Score: +2

Javier Bardem

as Captain Vincente De Santa in Red Dead Redemption

Score: 0