Suggestions by @yourstruly

Jared Stern

as Veovis in Myst Series

Score: -2

Amandla Stenberg

as The Stranger in Myst Series

Score: +3

Mark Ruffalo

as Atrus in Myst Series

Score: 0

Rosario Dawson

as Catherine/Katran in Myst Series

Score: +1

Tom Hiddleston

as Sirrus in Myst Series

Score: +1

Rand Miller

as Atrus in Myst Series

Score: +3

Jake Gyllenhaal

as John Ward in FAItH: The Unholy Trinity

Score: -1

Finn Wolfhard

as Micheal Davies in FAItH: The Unholy Trinity

Score: +1

Micheal sheen

as Gary in FAItH: The Unholy Trinity

Score: +3

Jon Hamm

as Father Allred in FAItH: The Unholy Trinity

Score: 0

Willem Dafoe

as Gary in FAItH: The Unholy Trinity

Score: -2

Oscar Isaac

as Father Garcia in FAItH: The Unholy Trinity

Score: -2

Grace McLean

as Rose Vanderboom in Rusty Lake: Roots

Score: -1

Alba Flores

as Ida Vanderboom in Rusty Lake: Roots

Score: -1

Hiba Abouk

as Ida Vanderboom in Rusty Lake: Roots

Score: 0

David Tennant

as Micheal ‘Mike’ Crew in The Magnus Archives (A Horror Anthology Podcast)

Score: -12

Natalie Dormer

as Alice ‘Daisy’ Tonner in The Magnus Archives (A Horror Anthology Podcast)

Score: -5

John Bradley

as Martin Blackwood in The Magnus Archives (A Horror Anthology Podcast)

Score: -11

Maisie Williams

as Sasha James in The Magnus Archives (A Horror Anthology Podcast)

Score: -24

Bill Skarsgård

as Micheal in The Magnus Archives (A Horror Anthology Podcast)

Score: +34