Suggestions by @xxlovelyxmessxx

Danielle Campbell

as Marisol Tourmaline in Once Upon A Broken Heart

Score: -2

Chloë Grace Moretz

as Evangeline Fox in Once Upon A Broken Heart

Score: -12

Shelley Hennig

as Madison Landry in One Tree Hill | Next Generation

Score: +2

Shelley Hennig

as Lily Roe Scott in One Tree Hill | Next Generation

Score: +2

Danielle Campbell

as Lily Roe Scott in One Tree Hill | Next Generation

Score: +2

Claire Holt

as Jenny Jagielski in One Tree Hill | Next Generation

Score: +2

Chloe Bennet

as Madison Landry in One Tree Hill | Next Generation

Score: +4

Jacob Artist

as Andre Fields in One Tree Hill | Next Generation

Score: +4

Keiynan Lonsdale

as Andre Fields in One Tree Hill | Next Generation

Score: +2

Sadie Sink

as Lydia Bob Scott in One Tree Hill | Next Generation

Score: +2

Kaylee Kaneshiro

as Calliope Adams (Callie) in One Tree Hill | Next Generation

Score: +2

Jaden Martell

as Brooks Walker in One Tree Hill | Next Generation

Score: +2

Jordan Fisher

as Noah Taylor in One Tree Hill | Next Generation

Score: +4

Mila Jones

as Aria Adams in One Tree Hill | Next Generation

Score: +3

Jacob Tremblay

as Quincy Scott in One Tree Hill | Next Generation

Score: +3

Nina Dobrev

as Lily Roe Scott in One Tree Hill | Next Generation

Score: +4

Liam Hemsworth

as Chuck Scolnik (Adams) in One Tree Hill | Next Generation

Score: +4

Dominic Sherwood

as Chuck Scolnik (Adams) in One Tree Hill | Next Generation

Score: +2

Dominic Sherwood

as Logan Evans in One Tree Hill | Next Generation

Score: +2

Scott Eastwood

as Logan Evans in One Tree Hill | Next Generation

Score: +4