Suggestions by @xxdisneyjunkie1984xx

Ty Burrell

as George Bear in Olaf and the Three Polar Bears

Score: +2

Jessica Chastain

as Kassandra in Warlock

Score: +2

John Krasinski

as Giles Redferne in Warlock

Score: +2

Norm Lewis

as Old Deuteronomy in Cats

Score: +5

Naoimh Morgan

as Rumpelteazer in Cats

Score: +5

Charlie Hunnam

as Mungojerie in Cats

Score: +1

Hugh Panaro

as Mr. Mistofelees in Cats

Score: +3

Kelsey Grammer

as Gus in Cats

Score: -1

Rebel Wilson

as Jennyanydots in Cats

Score: +1

Idris Elba

as Macavity in Cats

Score: +2

Jennifer Hudson

as Grizabella in Cats

Score: +4

Jason Derulo

as Rum Tum Tugger in Cats

Score: 0

David Alan Grier

as Old Deuteronomy in Cats

Score: -4

James Corden

as Bustopher Jones in Cats

Score: +1

Sierra Boggess

as Victoria in Cats

Score: +7

Andrew Lloyd Webber

as Composer in Cats

Score: +3

Seth Grahame-Smith

as Writer in The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad

Score: +1

Rob Marshall

as Director in The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad

Score: +1

Elizabeth Banks

as Edith Myers in Haddonfield

Score: +2

Margot Robbie

as Harleen Quinzel in Arkham

Score: +6