Suggestions by @wpmwow

Pedro Pascal

as Grendel in A Wolf Among Us Netflix Series

Score: -1

David Tennant

as Ichabod Crane in A Wolf Among Us Netflix Series

Score: +3

Joe Keery

as Jack Horner in A Wolf Among Us Netflix Series

Score: +1

Christina Applegate

as Lilly in A Wolf Among Us Netflix Series

Score: +2

Vincent D'Onofrio

as The Tweedles in A Wolf Among Us Netflix Series

Score: -1

Krysten Ritter

as Faith in A Wolf Among Us Netflix Series

Score: +1

Naveen Andrews

as Prince Lawrence in A Wolf Among Us Netflix Series

Score: +1

Elden Henson

as Colin the Pig in A Wolf Among Us Netflix Series

Score: +1

Chase Stokes

as Beast in A Wolf Among Us Netflix Series

Score: +2

Kiernan Shipka

as Beauty in A Wolf Among Us Netflix Series

Score: +1

Lars Mikkelsen

as The Woodsman in A Wolf Among Us Netflix Series

Score: -1

Bob Odenkirk

as Mr. Toad in A Wolf Among Us Netflix Series

Score: +2

Alison Brie

as Snow White in A Wolf Among Us Netflix Series

Score: +3

Gaten Matarazzo

as Toad Jr. in A Wolf Among Us Netflix Series

Score: +3

David Harbour

as Bigby in A Wolf Among Us Netflix Series

Score: +6