Suggestions by @wisdomspirit7

Jake Lacy

as Bruce Wayne in Superman (With The Office Cast)

Score: +2

Paul Lieberstein

as Moby Menderson in Superman (With The Office Cast)

Score: +2

B. J. Novak

as Steve Lombard in Superman (With The Office Cast)

Score: 0

Jenna Fischer

as Lana Lang in Superman (With The Office Cast)

Score: -1

Mindy Kaling

as Cat Grant in Superman (With The Office Cast)

Score: +3

Leslie David Baker

as Ron Troupe in Superman (With The Office Cast)

Score: 0

Ed Helms

as Jimmy Olsen in Superman (With The Office Cast)

Score: -1

Steve Carell

as Perry White in Superman (With The Office Cast)

Score: +4

Rainn Wilson

as Lex Luthor in Superman (With The Office Cast)

Score: +6

Jenna Fischer

as Lois Lane in Superman (With The Office Cast)

Score: +12

Emily Blunt

as Lois Lane in Superman (With The Office Cast)

Score: -1

John Krasinski

as Clark Kent/Kal-El in Superman (With The Office Cast)

Score: +11

Nick Frost

as Oswald Cobblepot in The Batman

Score: +1

Kristen Wiig

as Carol Danvers/Captain Marvel in The LEGO Marvel Movie

Score: -1