Suggestions by @willsheffield

Widowmaker

as Super Smash Bros. in Guest Characters We Want to see

Score: +2

Jennifer Corvino

as Dead by Daylight in Guest Characters We Want to see

Score: +2

Stripe (Gremlins)

as Dead by Daylight in Guest Characters We Want to see

Score: +2

The Blissfield Butcher

as Dead by Daylight in Guest Characters We Want to see

Score: +2

Daffy Duck

as Fortnite in Guest Characters We Want to see

Score: +1

Yusuke Urameshi

as Fortnite in Guest Characters We Want to see

Score: +1

Theresa "Tree" Gelbman

as Dead by Daylight in Guest Characters We Want to see

Score: +2

Tohru Adachi

as Dead by Daylight in Guest Characters We Want to see

Score: +2

Norman Bates

as Dead by Daylight in Guest Characters We Want to see

Score: +2

Pearl (Pearl)

as Dead by Daylight in Guest Characters We Want to see

Score: +2

Baby Firefly

as Dead by Daylight in Guest Characters We Want to see

Score: +2

Johnny (In A Violent Nature)

as Dead by Daylight in Guest Characters We Want to see

Score: +2

Roronoa Zoro

as Soulcalibur in Guest Characters We Want to see

Score: +1

Ichigo Kurosaki

as Soulcalibur in Guest Characters We Want to see

Score: +1

Andros/Red Space Ranger

as Fortnite in Guest Characters We Want to see

Score: +1

Renate Reinsve

as Fortnite in Guest Characters We Want to see

Score: +1

Rock Howard

as Tekken in Guest Characters We Want to see

Score: +1

Tifa Lockhart

as Tekken in Guest Characters We Want to see

Score: +1

Ike (Fire Emblem)

as Soulcalibur in Guest Characters We Want to see

Score: +1

Red Sonja

as Soulcalibur in Guest Characters We Want to see

Score: +1