Suggestions by @williamsapong

Ashly Burch

as Mela in Pokemon Scarlet and Violet (English Dub Fancast)

Score: +2

Bryce Papenbrook

as Giacomo in Pokemon Scarlet and Violet (English Dub Fancast)

Score: +2

Glenn Howerton

as Superman in Holy Musical B@man!

Score: +3

Christian Borle

as Andy Bernard in The office

Score: +1

Lauren Lopez

as Angela Martin in The office

Score: +1

Javier Muñoz

as Oscar Martinez in The office

Score: +2

Danny Skinner

as Kevin malone in The office

Score: +3

Kingsley Leggs

as Stanley Hudson in The office

Score: +2

Rob McClure

as Michael Scott in The office

Score: +2

Mary Kate Morrissey

as Undyne in Undertale The Musical

Score: +1

Neil Patrick Harris

as Mettaton in Undertale The Musical

Score: +1

Bryce Pinkham

as Papyrus in Undertale The Musical

Score: +1

Philippa Soo

as Toriel Dreemurr in Undertale The Musical

Score: +1

Maya Rudolph

as Aphrodite in Greek Mythology

Score: -7

Dave Bautista

as Shrek in Dreamworks animation live action fancast

Score: +2

Fred Tatasciore

as Apollo in Full Live Action Animal Crossing Fancast

Score: 0

Cheyenne Jackson

as Alex the Lion in Madagascar – A Musical Adventure

Score: -1

Rob McClure

as Melman the Giraffe in Madagascar – A Musical Adventure

Score: 0

Norm Lewis

as Thanos in Rogers the musical

Score: +2

Earl Carpenter

as Ebenezer Scrooge in A Christmas Carol (Broadway Musical)

Score: 0