Suggestions by @williamsapong

Charity Angel Dawson

as Gloria the Hippopotamus in Madagascar – A Musical Adventure

Score: 0

Bryce Pinkham

as Prince Charming in Shrek 2 the Musical

Score: +1

John Cariani

as Luigi Mario in Super Mario: The Broadway Musical

Score: 0

Brian Unger

as Seymour Skinner in The Simpsons

Score: 0

Larry the Cable Guy

as Jimbo in South Park

Score: +1

Glenn Howerton

as Megamind in Megamind the musical

Score: 0

Conrad Ricamora

as Frank ‘Grimey’ Grimes in The Simpsons

Score: +2

George Salazar

as Seymour in Little Shop of Horrors (2023 Remake)

Score: +1

Joshua Henry

as Knuckles the Echidna in Sonic Musical Adventure

Score: +5

Tom Alan Robbins

as Eli “Big Daddy” La Bouff in The Princess and the Frog (Broadway)

Score: +1

Jordan Donica

as Dr. Facilier in The Princess and the Frog (Broadway)

Score: -1

Annaleigh Ashford

as Charlotte La Bouff in The Princess and the Frog (Broadway)

Score: -2

Aaron Arnell Harrington

as Louis in The Princess and the Frog (Broadway)

Score: +2

Cleve September

as Prince Naveen in The Princess and the Frog (Broadway)

Score: +2

Jason Vande Brake

as Kamado in Pokemon Legends: Arceus Dubbed

Score: +1

Lucien Dodge

as Adaman in Pokemon Legends: Arceus Dubbed

Score: +1

Drew Carey

as Principal John Shepherd in Family Guy

Score: +3

Jason Alexander

as Principal John Shepherd in Family Guy

Score: +1

Annaleigh Ashford

as Honey in Space Dandy

Score: +1

Christian Borle

as Dandy in Space Dandy

Score: +1