Suggestions by @whiteboy1

Anne Bancroft

as Silk spectre 1 in Watchmen 90s

Score: +1

John Malkovich

as Moloch in Watchmen 90s

Score: +1

Alan Moore

as Writer in Watchmen 90s

Score: +1

John Carpenter

as Composer in Watchmen 90s

Score: +1

Burt Reynolds

as The comedian in Watchmen 90s

Score: +1

Richard Gere

as Dr Manhattan in Watchmen 90s

Score: +1

Rutger Hauer

as Night owl 1 in Watchmen 90s

Score: +1

Willem Dafoe

as Rorschach in Watchmen 90s

Score: +2

Michelle Pfeiffer

as Silk spectre 2 in Watchmen 90s

Score: +1

Susan Sarandon

as Silk spectre 1 in Watchmen 90s

Score: +1

Jeremy Irons

as Ozymandias in Watchmen 90s

Score: +1

Oliver Stone

as Director in Watchmen 90s

Score: +1

Michael Keaton

as Nite owl 2 in Watchmen 90s

Score: +1

Todd McFarlane

as Writer in Spider-Man (1980s)

Score: 0

John Hughes

as Director in Spider-Man (1980s)

Score: -2

Bruce Campbell

as Mysterio in Spider-Man (1980s)

Score: 0

Emilio Estevez

as Flash Thompson in Spider-Man (1980s)

Score: -1

Paul Gleason

as J. Jonah Jameson in Spider-Man (1980s)

Score: -2

Dylan Baker

as The lizard in Spider-Man (1980s)

Score: -2

Gene Wilder

as Doctor octopus in Spider-Man (1980s)

Score: -1