Suggestions by @werecrowstudios

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Solid Snake in Super Smash Bros. Universe

Score: +5

Seth Rogen

as Simon Pearson in Red Dead Redemption 2

Score: -11

Zazie Beetz

as Tilly Jackson in Red Dead Redemption 2

Score: +27

Rami Malek

as Joker in Batman: dark year (idea for a new batman movie)

Score: -3

Mark Hamill

as Uncle in Red Dead Redemption

Score: +2

Finn Wolfhard

as Jack Marston in Red Dead Redemption

Score: +2

Joaquin Phoenix

as Bill Williamson in Red Dead Redemption

Score: 0

Jeffrey Dean Morgan

as Dutch Van Der Linde in Red Dead Redemption

Score: +4

Norman Reedus

as John Marston in Red Dead Redemption

Score: -1

Winona Ryder

as Mother in Coraline

Score: +33

Keanu Reeves

as Batman in Zack Snyder's The Dark Knight Returns

Score: +2

Ezra Miller

as Fox McCloud in Star Fox (NCU)

Score: -6

Ezra Miller

as Fox McCloud in Star Fox 2: 64

Score: -3

Troy Baker

as Joel in The Last of Us

Score: -6

LaKeith Stanfield

as The Joker in The Batman

Score: 0

Christopher Nolan

as Director in HALO 3

Score: -1

Terry Crews

as Sergeant Johnson in HALO 3

Score: +1

Benedict Cumberbatch

as Gravemind in HALO 3

Score: +2

Neil Patrick Harris

as 343 Guilty Spark in HALO 3

Score: 0