Suggestions by @watchmen

Bill Hader

as Monty in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Score: +1

Robert Pattinson

as Mothman in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Score: +1

Scott Eastwood

as Dollar Bill in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Score: +1

Hugh Laurie

as Byron Lewis (old) in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Score: +1

Elizabeth Olsen

as Gretchen Slovak in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Score: +1

Catherine Disher

as Mrs. Musante in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Score: +1

Jason Statham

as The Iron Lid in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Score: +1

James Caan

as Larry Schexnayder (old) in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Score: +1

James McAvoy

as Larry Schexnayder in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Score: +1

Lucas Hedges

as Tino Musante in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Score: +1

Michael Cera

as The Frogman in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Score: +1

Melissa McCarthy

as Liberty Lassy in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Score: +1

Brian Baumgartner

as Hank in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Score: +1

Amber Heard

as The Slut in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Score: +1

Ray Abruzzo

as Mr. Musante in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Score: +1

Paul Dano

as The Liquidator in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Score: +1

Abby Ryder Fortson

as Laurie Juspeczyk (12 years old) in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Score: +1

Margot Robbie

as Silk Spectre in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Score: +1

Cameron Monaghan

as The Comedian (young) in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Score: +1

Mel Gibson

as The Comedian in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Score: +1