Suggestions by @wangobangy

Doug Bradley

as Martin Archimbaud in Outlast

Score: +3

James Wan

as Director in Outlast

Score: +1

Leigh Whannell

as Director in Outlast

Score: +2

Eli Roth

as Director in Outlast

Score: -2

Samuel Laflamme

as Composer in Outlast

Score: +2

Brad Dourif

as Rudolf Wernicke in Outlast

Score: +1

Bryan Cranston

as Richard Trager in Outlast

Score: -1

David Tennant

as Richard Trager in Outlast

Score: +1

Doug Jones

as The Walrider in Outlast

Score: +5

James McAvoy

as Miles Upshur in Outlast

Score: +5

Robert Pattinson

as Miles Upshur in Outlast

Score: -2

Willem Dafoe

as Richard Trager in Outlast

Score: +3

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Miles Upshur in Outlast

Score: +5

Tyler Mane

as Chris Walker in Outlast

Score: +1

Kane Hodder

as Chris Walker in Outlast

Score: +5