Suggestions by @wallywest06

Sarah Michelle Gellar

as Wonder Woman in Wonder Woman (2005)(story removed)

Score: +1

Djimon Hounsou

as Despero in The Master Builder (2004)(story removed)

Score: +1

Ben Affleck

as Batman in The Master Builder (2004)(story removed)

Score: +1

Nathan Fillion

as Hal Jordan in The Master Builder (2004)(story removed)

Score: +1

Corey Reynolds

as John Stewart in The Master Builder (2004)(story removed)

Score: +1

Lance Reddick

as Martian Manhunter in Batman: The Caped Crusader (2004)(story removed)

Score: +1

Ben Affleck

as Batman in Batman: The Caped Crusader (2004)(story removed)

Score: +1

Matt Damon

as Two-Face in Batman: The Caped Crusader (2004)(story removed)

Score: +1

Josh Hutcherson

as Robin in Batman: The Caped Crusader (2004)(story removed)

Score: +1

Christian Bale

as Batman in Batman: The Caped Crusader (2004)(story removed)

Score: -1

Christian Bale

as Batman/Bruce Wayne in DCEU Pre-2013(story removed)

Score: +1

Brandon Routh

as Superman/Clark Kent in DCEU Pre-2013(story removed)

Score: +1

Cobie Smulders

as Wonder Woman/Diana Prince in DCEU Pre-2013(story removed)

Score: +1

Justin Hartley

as Aquaman/Arthur Curry in DCEU Pre-2013(story removed)

Score: +1

Nathan Fillion

as Green Lantern/Hal Jordan in DCEU Pre-2013(story removed)

Score: +1

Elisha Cuthbert

as Supergirl/Kara in DCEU Pre-2013(story removed)

Score: +1

Ryan Reynolds

as The Flash/Barry Allen in DCEU Pre-2013(story removed)

Score: +1

Garrett Hedlund

as Green Arrow/Oliver Queen in DCEU Pre-2013(story removed)

Score: +1